FDA-registered facility · Same-day shipping by 2 PM Pacific
Talk to a human: (310) 415-7759

Holiday Returns 2026: How Shopify and TikTok Shop Brands Should Prepare Now

Retailers expect about 17% of holiday sales to come back, mostly in January. Here is how to set Shopify return rules, meet TikTok Shop deadlines and budget for 2027 return label fees before the wave hits.

Key Takeaways

  • Retailers surveyed by NRF and Happy Returns expected 17% of holiday sales to be returned; NRF releases new returns insights in mid-December 2026.
  • Shopify return rule changes apply only to future orders, so set holiday windows and final sale items before holiday orders are placed.
  • TikTok Shop sellers have 4 business days to answer return requests and 24 hours to submit dispute evidence, or refunds can go through automatically.
  • UPS return label fees rise from $1.15 to $1.25 per label on December 21, 2026, at list rates.
  • Write grading rules for apparel, cosmetics and supplements before January so returned units are restocked or written off consistently.

Most holiday returns arrive in January, and the best time to prepare for them is before the gifts ship. According to the National Retail Federation (NRF), retailers surveyed for its 2025 Retail Returns Landscape report with Happy Returns expected 17% of holiday sales to be returned, and 82% of shoppers said they return unwanted gifts within one month of receiving them. NRF forecasts 2026 holiday sales (November 1 through December 31) will grow 4.2% to $1.013 trillion. For Shopify and TikTok Shop brands in cosmetics, apparel and supplements, that means setting return rules, platform response routines and return label budgets now, because several of the settings only apply to orders placed after you change them.

How Many Holiday Orders Will Come Back?

NRF's latest published benchmark is the 17% holiday return expectation from its 2025 report. NRF says it will release new holiday returns insights in mid-December 2026, so treat 17% as a starting point and update it when the new numbers come out. Your own rate depends on category: apparel with size and fit questions usually runs higher than sealed skincare or supplements.

To turn the benchmark into a plan, multiply your forecast holiday sales by a return rate. At 17%, $200,000 in November and December sales means roughly $34,000 in merchandise coming back. Then spread that across weeks. NRF notes the vast majority of returns happen in January, and many shoppers use a return as a reason to buy something else during post-holiday sales. That second point matters: a return that turns into an exchange or store credit keeps the revenue.

What Shopify Return Settings Should You Change Before December?

Shopify's return rules live under Settings > Policies. The most important detail in Shopify's documentation: changes to return rules apply only to future orders. If you want a holiday return window to cover gifts bought in late November, set it before those orders are placed. Here is what you can control:

  • Return window: No returns, 14 days, 30 days, 90 days, Unlimited or a custom number of days.
  • Window start: from each item's delivery, or from delivery of the last item in the order. You can also extend a window that ends on a weekend or holiday to the next business day.
  • Return window overrides: a longer or shorter window for specific collections, products or variants. If an item falls under more than one override, Shopify uses the shortest one.
  • Return shipping: free return shipping, a flat fee charged once per return, or customers buy their own label.
  • Restocking fee: an optional percentage of the return.
  • Final sale items: products or collections (not both) that cannot be returned. Shopify lists perishable, custom and personal care items as examples. Bundles cannot be set as final sale.

Two more details trip up teams in January. Shopify does not deduct return fees from refunds automatically, so staff must deduct them when creating the refund. And since October 23, 2026, Shopify calculates tax on return shipping fees for US orders on Shopify Tax or Tax Platform, which we covered in our post on Shopify's return fee tax change.

How Do TikTok Shop Returns and Disputes Work?

TikTok Shop runs its own return clock, and missing it costs money. According to PPC Land's review of TikTok Shop's US dispute escalation policy, dated June 25, 2026:

  • Customer request window: 30 calendar days from delivery to request a return or refund.
  • Seller response: 4 business days. If you do not respond, the request is approved automatically.
  • Escalation: after a seller rejects a request, the customer has 10 calendar days to open a dispute.
  • Evidence deadline: 24 hours after a dispute notification. Missing it can mean an automatic refund at your expense.
  • Appeals: 21 calendar days after a decision.
  • Cosmetic allergy disputes: the customer must provide a medical certificate.

Over the holidays, those windows run through weekends and team time off. Assign someone to check TikTok Shop return requests every business day from late December through January, and keep proof of delivery, packing photos and product condition records easy to pull. TikTok Shop updates its policies often, so confirm the current terms in Seller Center.

What Will Return Labels Cost After December 21?

If you send customers UPS return labels, budget for the 2027 changes that start December 21, 2026, right before the January return wave. D'Arrigo Consulting's breakdown of UPS's published 2027 preview lists:

  • Print Return Label: $1.15 to $1.25 per label
  • Electronic Return Label: $1.15 to $1.25 per label
  • UPS Returns with 3 pickup attempts: $14.50 to $15.75
  • Address Correction: $25.25 to $27.50 per package

These are UPS list amounts, and your agreement may discount them. Transportation charges also rise, since UPS Daily Rates increase an average net 5.9% the same day. D'Arrigo also notes that UPS demand surcharge periods run through January 16, 2027, so late-December and early-January invoices can carry both new 2027 rates and peak charges. A quick check: 3,000 UPS return labels in January would cost $300 more in label fees alone at the higher rate, before postage.

How Should Cosmetics, Apparel and Supplement Brands Handle Returned Units?

Write the grading rules down before the volume arrives, so every returned unit gets the same decision:

  • Apparel: check tags, odor, makeup marks and wear at collars, underarms and hems. Restock sellable sizes fast, because January exchanges need that inventory. Our clothing returns guide has a simple three-grade standard.
  • Cosmetics and skincare: decide in advance whether opened or unsealed items can ever be restocked. Most brands treat them as unsellable. Consider marking hygiene-sensitive items as final sale in Shopify for future orders.
  • Supplements: confirm the seal is intact and check the lot and expiration date before anything goes back into sellable stock. A returned unit near its expiration date should not be the next one picked.
  • Gift sets and bundles: decide whether a partial return breaks the set, and whether the remaining items become singles or get written off.

What Is a Simple Holiday Returns Checklist?

  1. Forecast returns in dollars and units by week, starting from a rate like NRF's 17% and adjusting for your category.
  2. Update Shopify return rules now, since changes only apply to future orders. Set the window, start date, overrides and final sale items.
  3. Default to exchanges and store credit on your returns page, and post the holiday return deadline in order emails and your site banner.
  4. Staff TikTok Shop responses so no request passes the 4-business-day window and no dispute misses the 24-hour evidence deadline.
  5. Budget return labels at 2027 carrier amounts, not 2026.
  6. Write grading rules for each category and train whoever inspects returns.
  7. Book a returns reserve in December so January refunds do not distort your margin picture.

If you have not set your outbound order cutoffs yet, start with our 2026 holiday shipping deadlines. Orders that arrive on time are less likely to come back as late-gift returns.

How Matrix Fulfillment Helps

Matrix Fulfillment is a Los Angeles 3PL near the Port of Long Beach for Shopify, TikTok Shop and DTC brands in cosmetics, apparel and supplements. We run on ShipHero WMS, ship same day on orders received by 2 PM Pacific, and have maintained 99.8% accuracy across more than 1 million orders, which keeps wrong-item returns down. Our warehouse is FDA-registered with lot tracking and FEFO, so skincare and supplement inventory ships oldest-dated stock first. Terms are month-to-month with $0 setup fees, and pick and pack starts at $1.50 per order. To plan for 2027, request a quote.

Want Matrix to Handle This for You?

See how we fulfill orders for brands like yours.

Get a Shopify Fulfillment QuoteGet a Quote

Frequently Asked Questions

What percentage of holiday sales are returned?

Retailers surveyed by NRF and Happy Returns for the 2025 Retail Returns Landscape report expected 17% of holiday sales to be returned. NRF says it will release new holiday returns insights in mid-December 2026.

When do most holiday returns happen?

NRF says the vast majority of returns occur in January, and 82% of shoppers say they return unwanted holiday gifts within one month of receiving them.

Do Shopify return rule changes apply to existing orders?

No. Shopify says changes to return rules apply only to future orders, so set your holiday return window before holiday orders are placed.

How long do TikTok Shop sellers have to respond to return requests?

Under TikTok Shop's US dispute policy dated June 25, 2026, sellers have 4 business days to respond to a return or refund request, or it is approved automatically. In a dispute, sellers have 24 hours to submit evidence.

How much will UPS return labels cost in 2027?

From December 21, 2026, UPS Print Return Label and Electronic Return Label fees rise from $1.15 to $1.25 per label at list rates, according to D'Arrigo Consulting's review of UPS's 2027 preview.

Sources

Talk to a Fulfillment Expert

Questions about this topic or your shipping costs? We reply within one business day.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.