Shopify Now Taxes Return Shipping Fees: What Brands Need to Check
Since October 23, 2026, Shopify calculates sales tax on return shipping fees for US orders when stores use Shopify Tax or Tax Platform. Here is who is affected, what is excluded and how to avoid collecting the tax twice.
Key Takeaways
- Since October 23, 2026, Shopify calculates tax on return shipping fees for US orders on Shopify Tax or Tax Platform.
- Return shipping fees follow your existing shipping tax rules, so they stay untaxed in states where shipping is untaxed.
- Restocking fees are never taxed, and international, Manual Tax, Basic Tax and tax-exempt orders are excluded.
- Brands that added tax to return fees manually should turn off that workaround to avoid double-counting.
- Return fees are still not auto-deducted from refunds, so teams deduct them manually.
Yes. Since October 23, 2026, Shopify automatically calculates sales tax on the return shipping fee you charge a customer, as long as three things are true: the order shipped to a US address, you use Shopify Tax or Tax Platform, and shipping is taxable in the destination jurisdiction. If shipping is untaxed in a state, the return shipping fee stays untaxed there. Restocking fees are never taxed under this change. If you were already adding tax to return fees by hand, through an accounting rule or through an app, review that process now so you do not collect or report the tax twice.
What Exactly Did Shopify Change on October 23, 2026?
Shopify announced the change in its changelog on September 25, 2026. Return shipping fees are now "taxed like any other shipping charge," following the shipping tax settings your store already has. Before this date, a return shipping fee could show $0 in tax even in states where shipping is taxable.
Here is how the new flow works inside Shopify:
- Creating a return: you see the estimated tax next to the return shipping fee.
- Processing a return: Shopify records the final tax amount, and it is included in the return's total tax.
- Reporting: the tax flows into your Shopify tax reports automatically.
- Settings: nothing new to turn on. Existing shipping tax rules decide whether the fee is taxed.
Which Shopify Stores Are Affected?
According to Shopify's return rules documentation, tax is calculated on a return shipping fee only when all of these apply:
- The original order shipped to a US address.
- The store uses Shopify Tax or Tax Platform.
- The fee is taxable in the destination jurisdiction.
Tax is not calculated on a return shipping fee if the order shipped outside the US, if the store uses another tax service such as Manual Tax or Basic Tax, or if the order is tax exempt. Returns with no return shipping charge are also unaffected, because there is no fee to tax.
If you offer free returns, nothing changes for you. If you charge a flat return fee or a fee per return, this change applies to your US orders whenever the destination state taxes shipping.
Does Shopify Tax Restocking Fees or Handling Fees on Returns?
No. Shopify's documentation states that tax is never calculated on restocking fees. ShipAid's explainer on the change also lists handling fees and international returns as outside the scope of the update. That matters for reporting: if your returns app or support team lumps a return label charge and a restocking charge into one line, you will want to separate them so the taxable and non-taxable portions are clear.
How Does Shopify Decide Whether Shipping Is Taxable?
For US orders, Shopify calculates shipping tax automatically where it applies, regardless of the "Charge tax on shipping rates" setting. That setting only affects countries and regions where tax is not calculated automatically. State rules differ. Shopify's shipping tax page uses Colorado as an example, where you choose whether to collect tax on shipping when you set up your registration there.
Because return shipping fees now follow those same rules, the states where your outbound shipping is taxed are the same states where your return shipping fees will be taxed. Shopify notes that its tax pages are informational and not professional tax advice, so confirm state specifics with your accountant.
Who Needs to Take Action?
Shopify says most merchants on Shopify Tax or Tax Platform need to do nothing. The group that does need to act is any brand that built a workaround before October 23 to calculate, collect, import or reconcile tax on return shipping fees. If that workaround keeps running, the same tax could be counted twice: once by Shopify and once by your spreadsheet, accounting rule or app.
What Should Brands Check Before Holiday Returns Arrive?
Holiday orders shipped in November and December turn into January returns, so the time to clean this up is before peak. A practical checklist, based on Shopify's guidance and ShipAid's walkthrough:
- Map every place a return fee is created. That includes Shopify's native returns, any returns app, support team macros and manual refunds in the admin.
- Find manual tax steps. Look for spreadsheets, accounting rules or app settings that add tax to return fees, and turn them off or adjust them if Shopify is now handling it.
- Review shipping tax by state. Know which of your shipping destinations tax shipping, since return fees now follow the same rules.
- Separate fee types in reporting. Keep return shipping fees apart from restocking fees so taxable and non-taxable amounts are easy to reconcile.
- Remember fees are not auto-deducted. Shopify's return rules page says return fees are not automatically deducted from refunds. You still deduct them manually when you create the refund, so train your team on the new tax line.
- Run a test return. Process one test return to a taxable state and confirm the estimated tax matches the recorded amount and your books show a single tax entry.
Will This Change What Customers Pay to Return Items?
In states that tax shipping, yes, slightly. A customer who pays a flat return fee will now see tax added to it. ShipAid points out that even a small added amount shows up right when the shopper is deciding whether to return, and that flat fees weigh more heavily on low-value orders. For cosmetics, apparel and supplement brands with lower average order values, it is worth checking whether your current flat return fee still makes sense once tax is added in your biggest states.
Shopify's return rules let you choose free return shipping, a flat-rate fee charged once per return, or having the customer buy their own label, and you can edit the fee on each return. You can also mark specific products or collections as final sale so they are excluded from returns. Shopify lists personal care items as one example.
How Matrix Fulfillment Helps
Tax on return fees is a bookkeeping change, but the cheapest return is the one that never happens. Matrix Fulfillment ships Shopify, TikTok Shop and DTC orders from our Los Angeles warehouse near the Port of Long Beach, running on ShipHero WMS with 99.8% accuracy across more than 1 million orders. Orders placed by 2 PM Pacific ship the same day, which keeps holiday orders moving before carrier cutoffs. For cosmetics and supplements, we are FDA-registered with lot tracking and FEFO, so the right lot goes out first. Pricing starts at $1.50 per order, month-to-month, with no setup fees.
Want to see what your fulfillment would cost? Get a Shopify fulfillment quote.
Want Matrix to Handle This for You?
See how we fulfill orders for brands like yours.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Shopify charge tax on return shipping fees?
Yes, starting October 23, 2026, for orders shipped to US addresses when the store uses Shopify Tax or Tax Platform and shipping is taxable in the destination jurisdiction.
Are restocking fees taxed in Shopify?
No. Shopify's documentation says tax is never calculated on restocking fees.
Does the change apply to international returns?
No. Tax is not calculated on return shipping fees for orders shipped outside the US, for stores using Manual Tax or Basic Tax, or for tax-exempt orders.
Do I need to change any Shopify settings?
Most merchants need no action because existing shipping tax settings apply. Merchants who manually calculated, collected or reconciled tax on return fees should review that process to avoid double-counting tax.
Are return fees deducted from refunds automatically?
No. Shopify's return rules page says return fees are not automatically deducted from refunds, so you deduct them manually when you create the refund.